TIFF 2020

Shadow in the Cloud review – downright revolutionary feminist actioner

This thrilling and empowering debut from Roseanne Liang finally understands how women can - and should - lead the action genre

It’s a real thrill to find, in what could have been yet another schlocky, derivative horror flick, a worthy successor to Alien’s iconic heroine Ellen Ripley: a complex, challenging woman in an environment that so often pretends we don’t exist. Shadow in the Cloud – a haywire WWII action movie with more twists than the Rainbow Road track in Mario Kart – relishes the chance to flip the narrative while preserving so much of the genre’s best conventions. It’s silly, sometimes scary, truly outstanding.

We are led by Chloë Grace Moretz as pilot Maude Garrett as she joins a B-17 Flying Fortress alongside a ragtag crew of men who live to belittle her. But she’s there to do her job, to protect a top secret package, and soon to deal with the evil presence running around in the clouds just outside. It may or may not be an army of gremlins (the year is 1943, when – that’s right – Roald Dahl released his first book: The Gremlins), and the men may or may not prefer to gaslight and patronise Maude instead of working together to defeat the monsters lurking just out of sight. Think The Twilight Zone, if feminism had been on anyone’s radar back then.

To reveal more of the plot details would ruin the ludicrous fun, since writer-director Roseanne Liang lives to surprise her audience. Shadow in the Cloud is the sort of outrageously entertaining thriller that demands a full-body reaction – whether you’re screeching along in a sold-out cinema, or clapping in disbelief from the comfort of your own home. It’s a true mark of success that in times of isolated virtual cinema-going, something played on a small screen could demand such an enormous response.

Moretz is incandescent as Maude – sharp and smart enough to hold her own against every man, entertaining enough to always hold the viewer’s attention at every turn. Liang’s vision is nothing short of revolutionary, as Shadow in the Cloud not only adapts the genre’s template to make sense for a female hero, but also makes it impossible for a male character to even try. The filmmaker flirts with familiar stereotypes – Women are hysterical! Men will save us! – but then pushes them into new territory when the monsters come out to play. These boys have done their best, but ultimately it’s up to Maude, and her top secret package, to save us all. Her body, her instincts, and her bravery are her greatest tools – habits that have always felt natural  to a woman, to take care of your loved ones as if the world depends on it, are now viewed as superpowers. Watching the men here as they witness Moretz tearing up the rulebook of onscreen violence makes for one of the most rewarding final acts in recent history.

That’s not to say this is the most intellectual or elegant action movie ever, but it doesn’t need to be. In a year plagued by a lack of enthusiasm from tired audiences, Shadow in the Cloud feels like a breath of fresh air and a fire-breathing dragon both at once. It’s genre cinema at its finest, a thrilling step forward for the women who have spent their lives whooping and dreaming behind the scenes, never quite in charge of who these heroes are, or how they fight. Finally, Ripley has some worthy company.

Shadow in the Cloud was screened as part of the Toronto International Film Festival 2020. A UK release date is yet to be announced.

Where to watch

More Reviews...

Pixie review – silly but joyous Irish spaghetti western

Olivia Cooke shines as the enigmatic title character in this bonkers genre subversion, co-starring Alec Baldwin as a drug-dealing priest

David Byrne’s American Utopia review – a comfort blanket for troubled times

The inimitable Talking Heads frontman teams with Spike Lee for this joyous celebration of where we are and where we're going

Bruce Springsteen’s Letter to You review – stirring and transcendent making-of

The Boss's first collaboration with the full E Street Band in over 35 years is brought to life in this brilliantly spirited documentary

Totally Under Control review – intermittently astonishing COVID doc

Alex Gibney's look at America's disastrous handling of the pandemic is studious and important, even as it peters out


Tracey Deer on Beans: “There is still so much work to be done”

The filmmaker is trying to reshape Canadians’ understanding of the country’s Indigenous community. Adam Solomons talks to the TIFF prize-winner about her debut narrative feature

Best of the Fest: 12 Essential Films From BFI LFF 2020

We've gathered up our most glowing reviews from this year's festival, from groundbreaking animation to dizzying debuts

Best Films to Watch in London and Stream This Week

From cinema releases to streaming gems, including a meditation of male friendship and the return of everyone's favourite Kazakh reporter

Every Sofia Coppola Film, Ranked

The Bling Ring or The Beguiled? With On the Rocks now in cinemas, Ella Kemp sorts through the filmmaker's sumptuous canon so far...