Streaming Review

Comets review – short but fatally dull Georgian romance

Tamar Shavgulidze’s unpredictable tale of a past relationship barely scrapes feature length, but will test your patience anyway

Within its opening 10 minutes, you might feel as if you’ve got the number of Comets, an opaque Georgian sort-of-romantic drama. A 10-ish minute unbroken, static-camera take of a mother and her adult daughter gently arguing whilst the mother prepares some freshly-picked blackberries, it looks like a committed and placid slice of social realism. This assumption is soon interrupted, though, by the arrival of a past lover, and shifted yet again towards the end by a sharp left turn into impressionistic sci-fi. It’s an ambitious array of genres spanned in just 70 minutes, yet, somehow, Comets still manages to be fatally boring.

The mother in question is 50-something Nana (Ketevan Gegeshidze), living with daughter Irina (Ekaterine Kalatozishvili), and seemingly trapped in a semi-content boredom that is upended when a different Irina (Nino Kasradze) makes a surprise visit. This Irina was Nana’s secret girlfriend back when the pair were teenagers and has since moved away from Georgia for a more glamorous life in Poland and Germany.

Though writer-director Tamar Shavgulidze’s intercutting of the past and present makes for some disarming moments, this reunion is mostly just underpowered. There are a lot of endless, slightly resentful conversations about the past and the different paths the pair’s lives have taken since then, and Shavgulidze’s stationary camerawork and lack of score gives this plodding story nowhere to hide, while the incredibly reserved performances only add to the boredom.

For a movie that barely qualifies as feature length, there’s no excuse for so much of it to be this dull, and though the sci-fi leap at the climax does perk the whole endeavour up somewhat, it’s too little too late.

Comets is now streaming on MUBI.

Where to watch

More Reviews...

The Road Dance review – a remote and distant Scottish period drama

Great performances and rich atmosphere can't draw attention away from this film’s muddied sexual assault plot

Benediction review – a devastating ballad from Britain’s greatest living filmmaker

Terence Davies delivers another immensely personal lament, based on the life of English soldier and war poet Siegfried Sassoon

This Much I Know to Be True review – incandescent Nick Cave concert film

Andrew Dominik reunites with the Australian singer-songwriter for a documentary that is both intimate and epic in equal measure

The Drover’s Wife review – effective and stirring revisionist western

Leah Purcell writes, directs and stars in this refreshingly feminist and well acted revenge tale, set in colonial Australia


5 Must-Watch Features at Queer East Film Festival 2022

As the latest edition of the LGBTQ+ festival returns to London, we highlight our picks for the most essential features...

Avatar’s The Way of Water Trailer Will Actually Make You Excited About Avatar

Thirteen years after James Cameron's revolutionary blockbuster hit cinemas, we finally get a glimpse of its bigger, wetter sequel...

Every Spider-Man Film, Ranked

With Sam Raimi's original game-changing blockbuster turning 20 this week, we take stock of the web-slinger's filmic ventures so far...

Stream With a Theme: The Best Nun Films

As Paul Verhoeven's audacious Benedetta lands in cinemas, Steph Green highlights some worthy features about cinematic Sisters...