TIFF 2020

One Night in Miami review – brilliantly acted alternate history

Regina King’s directorial debut is a formidable what-if centred around four Black American icons, bolstered by great performances

One of the most talked-about moments in recent hit basketball documentary series The Last Dance was a segment on Michael Jordan’s reluctance to comment on politics. A rare apolitical celebrity with an unrivalled platform, Jordan’s cold neutrality sparked disappointment from the likes of Barack Obama. One Night in Miami, which marks actor-turned-filmmaker Regina King’s impressive feature debut, is about four Black celebrities who didn’t have that luxury.

Sam Cooke (Leslie Odom Jr.), Malcolm X (Kingsley Ben-Adir), Jim Brown (Aldis Hodge) and Cassius Clay (Eli Goree) never really met in Miami on February 25, 1964, the night that the 22-year-old Clay became the World Heavyweight Champion and reportedly made the decision to become Muhammad Ali. But playwright Kemp Powers (adapting his own work for this film adaptation) imagines that day as a turning point in the lives of all four. Despite the odd unwanted hallmark of a traditional biopic – clunky contextual information included – these four brilliant characterisations quickly distract from any glimpses of inexperience, as King understands how to focus on substance and sincerity.

The enticing premise works to a brilliant extent. In large part thanks to stellar performances across the board – and stunning work from Ben-Adir and Hamilton’s Odom Jr. in particular – One Night in Miami is a tremendously moving film and a profound alternative history in its own right. Crucially, King and cinematographer Tami Reiker bring some much needed style to what could have otherwise been a visually dull affair.

The primary tension here is between Malcolm X and the decidedly cautious Cooke, a suave showman whose predominantly white fan base (at least in 1964) prevented any shows of radicalism. The minister tells him sternly in a tense encounter: “The only person white people seem to like round here is you.” He’s not wrong, although there’s plenty of learning to be done on all sides – ours included.

It’s not a spoiler to say that One Night in Miami builds to quite the payoff: Cooke writing one of the best songs of the 20th century; Clay's transformation into the most charismatic man in the world, an icon of American Islam. This film doesn’t fixate on either man’s finest hour, but it does pose a compelling mythology as to how they got there. That One Night in Miami also marks King’s arrival as bonafide filmmaking talent makes it all the more sweeter.

One Night in Miami was screened as part of the Toronto International Film Festival 2020.

Where to watch

More Reviews...

Wild Mountain Thyme review – head-scratching romcom with a baffling sting

Emily Blunt and Christopher Walken butcher the Irish accent in a bizarre and pointless but somewhat fascinating filmic misfire

Without Remorse review – Michael B. Jordan can’t elevate a generic thriller

A couple of fun set-pieces aside, the latest big screen take on Tom Clancy is likely to fill you with a deep-seated regret of your own

The Mitchells vs. the Machines review – a charming and frenetic delight

The latest from Lord and Miller is a hilarious and hyperactive modern adventure that really will win over the entire family

Things Heard & Seen review – compellingly muddled ghost story

Amanda Seyfried and James Norton co-star in a domestic abuse horror that's more concerned with big ideas than big scares

Features

Best Films to Stream This Week in the UK

With cinemas still closed, we highlight the best new streaming releases, from this year's big Oscar winner to a Japanese swan song

Leonardo DiCaprio Orders an American Remake of Another Round

Appian Way have won the remake rights to the Oscar-winning tale of debauchery and dancing, with DiCaprio potentially poised to star

Whistle Along to the Teaser Trailer for Steven Spielberg’s West Side Story

Ansel Elgort and Rachel Zegler co-star in the legendary Hollywood director's take on the 1961 Best Picture winner

Oscars 2021: Nomadland Takes Home Best Picture, Best Actress & Best Director

Chloé Zhao makes history as first Asian woman to win Best Director, while Frances McDormand claims her third Oscar for Best Actress