Richard Jewell review – a real human being, if not a real hero

Clint Eastwood’s latest deconstruction of heroism finds the perfect cinematic approach to adapting true stories

“We’re going for authenticity here,” explains FBI agent Tom Shaw (Jon Hamm) to dubious security guard Richard Jewell (Paul Walter Hauser), who has been instructed to sign a form “for real” as another agent points a camera in his direction. Jewell is being led to believe that the FBI want his help in devising a training video for officers who, like him, may one day notice a suspicious bag in a public place and have to take action. Eastwood lets the awkward scene play in real time as Jewell gradually realises that he’s actually being interrogated as a suspect in the very terrorist attack he helped prevent: the form is not just a piece of paper, but an official document that will allow the FBI to use this video testimony against him. Jewell eventually refuses to sign, stops answering questions, and calls his lawyer.

With Richard Jewell, Clint Eastwood once again tells the ironic story of a man that society first deemed a hero, then accused of the crime he saved them from. Jewell was working as a low-level security guard when he helped the police contain a terrorist attack during the 1996 Summer Olympics in Atlanta, Georgia after he discovered an abandoned bag and insisted on establishing a security perimeter around it; three days later, however, the media and the police turned against him.

Compared to Sully or The 15:17 to Paris, the director’s previous hero tales based on true events, Richard Jewell sees Eastwood’s filmmaking and the specific subject matter come together more harmoniously than ever. The disguised interrogation scene showcases Eastwood’s understanding of what is at stake when a man sees himself being reduced to either a hero or a villain: the matter of authenticity – of true humanity – is under threat. Eastwood therefore emphasises realism: none of the uncomfortable pauses or hesitations are cut out in order to make the scene more palatable to audiences. The actors’ performances, too, are unusually naturalistic for Hollywood cinema today. Eastwood allows Jewell to appear as his true, complex, contradictory self – the better to reveal the FBI’s dangerous close-mindedness.

This slice-of-life style is what makes Richard Jewell more emotionally resonant than Sully, where the titular character didn’t possess the same degree of ordinariness: while Sullenberger was a likeable plane pilot portrayed by Classic Everyman but Huge Star Tom Hanks, Jewell is an awkward and overweight failed policeman turned security guard, as interpreted by the relatively unknown yet excellent actor Paul Walter Hauser. The veneer of Hollywood filmmaking is reduced to a minimum to better let the story’s humane complexity shine. Eastwood had already tried to come closer to reality in The 15:17 to Paris by having the real-life heroes play themselves in the reenactment of their anti-terrorist adventure; the result, however, had been more fascinatingly strange than impactful. Richard Jewell strikes the right balance between the cinematic and the non-fictional, letting professional actors portray real people in all their captivating messiness. 

For Jewell is far from a typical heroic figure: his obsession with law enforcement and inability to join its ranks made him a perfect candidate for the “heroic bomber” profile, a man who would place explosives then alert the authorities to gain media recognition. Eastwood and Hauser must have worked in tight collaboration in order to let Jewell appear often shockingly naive and clumsy, without the film ever judging or mocking him.

Such a simultaneously endearing and frustrating man is the ideal protagonist for Eastwood’s mission to challenge not only the value of the term “hero,” but also the ways in which society and the media use this concept to dehumanise people. When a man becomes a hero, his authentic, flawed self is discredited and an idealised new identity forced upon him – a fabricated image that he can’t possibly live up to. Jewell couldn’t even pretend to be the calm, cool and collected ordinary citizen that Sully was; Eastwood gives him back his humanity by showing his flaws without apologising for them. Nothing is sugar-coated and there are no heroes or villains: even Agent Shaw’s misjudged accusation is shown for what it really is – the reaction of a man who felt guilty for failing to better protect his community. With Richard Jewell, Eastwood has perfected his cinematic approach to real stories to become one of the most humanistic, bold, and morally invigorating American filmmakers today.

Find showtimes nearby

More Reviews...

The Lawyer review – unique and hyper-focused character study

This landmark drama from Lithuanian filmmaker Romas Zabarauskas tells of a privileged gay man’s emotional reckoning

The Whalebone Box review – disorienting docudrama defies description

This experimental work from filmmaker Andrew Köttin chronicles a strange journey to return a mythical object to its place of origin

Standing Up, Falling Down review – a plane movie you can watch at home

Ben Schwartz and Billy Crystal star as a failed comedian and a dermatologist who strike up in a friendship in this affable comedy

Lady and the Tramp review – charming and harmless update of a classic

Charlie Bean’s live-action remake might not be revolutionary, but there’s enough music and romance to make it shine

Features

Best Films to Stream This Week in the UK

From an affable Billy Crystal comedy to a Meghan Markle-narrated elephant doc, here are our top picks for streaming and renting...

7 Latest Studio Ghibli Films on Netflix, Ranked

As the streaming giant adds the final batch of Studio Ghibli features to its platform, we suggest which ones to prioritise in your queue

My Favourite Film Ending: Little Women

In the first of a new series, our writers sing the praises of their favourite film endings. This week, Ella Kemp celebrates the subversive climax of Greta Gerwig's Little Women

Seven Days of Streaming: The Enigmatic Roles of Robert Pattinson

From the anxious Good Time to the cosmic High Life, here's how to curate your own Robert Pattinson season at home in seven key films