In Cinemas

Spiral: From the Book of Saw review – ugly and witless torture porn reboot

Based on an idea by Chris Rock, the latest entry in the long-running horror franchise is suffocatingly self-serious and dull

When it was first announced that Chris Rock would be producing and starring in a Saw sequel it was an intriguing prospect. He didn’t seem the obvious fit for the franchise, but his unique voice, combined with other recent comedy-to-horror transitions like the Halloween reboot and Jordan Peele’s superb directorial work, gave a promising air to the project. Sadly, it has not panned out well and Spiral (with its absurd “From the Book of Saw” subtitle) arrives as a witless and overly self-serious affair that is unlikely to appeal to series fans or win over new viewers.

Rock stars as Detective Zeke Banks, the only clean cop in a deeply corrupt precinct in an unspecified city. Distrusted by his fellow officers, he’s partnered up with idealistic rookie William Schenk (Max Minghella) as he hunts a serial killer who seems to be targeting his corrupt colleagues, killing them with elaborate traps in much the same way as original Saw baddie Jigsaw.

Banks’s hunt for the killer is never all that compelling, the story’s twists and turns obvious from a mile away to the point that you’re basically just going through the motions until the film confirms a suspicion you’ve had for the past 30 minutes. It doesn’t help that Josh Stolberg and Peter Goldfinger’s script (notably, Rock has no writing credit) is absolutely leaden, weighed down with poorly handled exposition and never landing the political blows it wants to, all delivered by a mostly piss-poor cast.

Rock’s performance occasionally raises a smile, but Minghella and Samuel L. Jackson – playing Zeke’s high-ranking father Marcus – just seem bored, while the supporting actors are dire. This extends to the villain, who never manages to raise the air of charismatic menace that Tobin Bell brought to Jigsaw, and even the gory, gruesome traps aren’t that interesting.

Yes, there’s some wince-inducing body horror as tongues and fingers are torn asunder, but nothing here is anywhere near as iconic as the needle pit or reverse bear trap from previous instalments. Their inclusion mostly feels forced, necessities to tie Spiral in to the rest of the Saw franchise, but without much imagination put into their actual construction.

Director Darren Lynn Bousman doesn’t limit his aping of the original franchise to just the traps, though – every scene of Spiral seems to lift all its stylistic tics from the mid-noughties, making everything look immediately dated. The ugly visuals, all jaundiced yellows and sweaty sheens, are forgivable in a film about gruesome torture, but the fact that Spiral often looks like a parody of itself is not.

Long term Saw fans will be let down by the scarcity of inventive traps here, while other viewers will be put off by the gore and general unpleasant scuzziness that coats every second. This is a reboot for nobody, dragging a franchise that belonged in the 2000s into the 2020s while completely forgetting to offer anything new. Chris Rock is a unique and brilliant American talent, one who deserves more than Hollywood has been willing to offer him, but this is a massive misstep for him both in front of and behind the camera.

Spiral: From the Book of Saw is now showing in UK cinemas.

Where to watch

More Reviews...

In the Heights review – intoxicating musical is the film of the summer

Jon M. Chu's screen adaptation of the acclaimed Lin-Manuel Miranda musical is a relentlessly joyous explosion of life and colour

One in a Thousand review – a well-crafted tale of young queer love

Writer-director Clarisa Navas helms an impressive and highly personal story of romance set in a poor neighbourhood in Argentina

The Hitman’s Wife’s Bodyguard review – a heinous and incomprehensible sequel

Ryan Reynolds's self-aware schtick wears dangerously thin in an ugly follow-up that seems to hate its own cast and audience

Fargo review – a yahsterpiece of the highest order

Is the Coens' chilly neo-noir about a simple kidnapping plot gone very wrong still as inspired as it was back in 1996? You betcha!


What Is the Best Scene in a Musical Film?

To mark the arrival of In the Heights in cinemas everywhere, our writers weigh in on their favourite musical numbers

Best Films to Watch in London and Stream This Week

With UK cinemas back in business, we highlight the best of what's new, from an intoxicating movie musical to Pixar's latest gem

Why I Changed My Mind About… The Royal Tenenbaums

Next in our series about films our writers have reconsidered, Emily Maskell on how grief changed her view of Wes Anderson's comedy

20 Unmissable Films Still to Come in 2021, Ranked by How Excited You Should Be

Beatles! Broadway! Beautiful boys! With seven months of the year still to go, Ella Kemp weighs up the biggest UK cinema releases...